An empty teak bench beneath a live oak beside a quiet sandy Gulf Coast bayfront in warm afternoon light.

The A&G Theater Keeps Getting New Plans on Paper. Here's Where Beach Boulevard's Dark Landmark Stands

November 12, 2026

In the spring of 1928, the new theater at 150 North Beach Boulevard got a top-of-the-line organ. Later that year it started showing talking films. Almost a century later, the Sun Herald described the interior with exposed brick on a fading wall and birds chirping in the rafters. The sloping floor and tall ceilings are still in place. The awning, balcony and marquee are gone.

The A&G has never been short of ideas. Over the past eight years one owner has filed or announced at least four different futures for it. Each one ran into the same obstacle. The building was made to do one thing, and anything else means rebuilding the inside.

Every Plan on Record Since 2018

Year What was proposed Where it stands
2018 A multipurpose venue for movies, theater, standup comedy, parties and weddings, after the owner had a movies-only restriction removed from the title Design process announced; no venue opened
December 2024 A flea market with rentable art booths, an added second floor, an elevator, stairs and restrooms Historic Preservation Commission approved exterior work; the building was listed for sale the following spring
June 2025 Listed at $2.2 million, with a movie theater, entertainment venue or shops as fallback designs No buyer by September 2026
September 2026 Listed near $2 million; a meeting with a comedy club about a sale or lease, and a possible blues club later Most recent reported plan

New Orleans developer Jim MacPhaille is behind every one of these plans. He announced the 2018 venue, his A&G Theatre LLC is named on the 2024 preservation filing, and the Sun Herald identified him as the owner in both 2025 and 2026. The asking price fell about $200,000 between the June 2025 listing and the September 2026 report. Over those fifteen months the building stayed as it was.

The First Fix Was on Paper

MacPhaille's first move did not touch the building. In 2018 he told WLOX that "the previous owners had a restriction on the title that they wanted it to be only a movie theatre," and that he had worked to get it removed. With the restriction gone, he said, "We can have parties, wedding venues, have standup comedy, have theatre, have movies. The possibilities are endless."

That restriction has a history. The theater went dark sometime around the 1970s, and according to the Sun Herald, local real estate agent Margaret Hayden bought it then because she could not bear the thought of it being torn down. Since the screen went dark, the only business to open inside has been a sno-ball stand. Clearing the title made other uses legal. It did not make them practical.

The December 2024 flea market plan shows how much work a practical reuse takes. A movie house with a sloping floor would need a new second floor, an elevator, stairs, restrooms and all-new mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems before vendors could rent booths. The minutes of the Historic Preservation Commission's December 9, 2024 meeting record approval of the outside changes: code-compliant entries, a loading door, replacement windows in the existing openings, paving and a trash enclosure. Four months later, in April 2025, the building went up for sale.

Because it is on the National Register, as the Sun Herald has reported, the building's identity matters as much as its floor plan. The state's historic inventory lists it as a Spanish-style theater, built in 1927 for $60,000 by owners Ames and Gaspard, which is where "A&G" comes from. It was renovated after heavy damage in Hurricane Katrina. It was one of the few Beach Boulevard buildings still standing after the storm, and it stayed empty while new bars and restaurants went up around it. Commission member Steve Haas put it plainly to the Sun Herald:

"It was always just sort of a vacant ghost."

The Same Architect Designed a Building That Found Its Path First

The state inventory names the A&G's designer as New Orleans architect William T. Nolan. Nolan also designed the Second Street School, built in 1927 at the corner of Ulman Avenue and North Second Street. MacPhaille owns both buildings.

The school has been empty since Katrina, and its route has not been smooth either. MacPhaille first planned a boutique hotel there and withdrew the plan after some neighbors objected to the zoning change it required. The property was listed for sale in 2025. In September 2026, the Sun Herald reported that construction was starting on a conversion of the roughly 47,000-square-foot campus into more than a dozen high-end condos over the next few years, possibly with a spa or Pilates studio. MacPhaille compared it to the LaSalle School Condominiums in Uptown New Orleans.

The school campus covers roughly 47,000 square feet, and MacPhaille has a finished schoolhouse-to-condo conversion in New Orleans to point to. The A&G is about 5,000 square feet of theater with a sloping floor, built to show movies. Whatever comes next has to make that space pay for itself as it is or pay for rebuilding it. MacPhaille's September remarks follow that order. The comedy club conversation was first, and the blues club idea was set for after the condo project.

Two More Dark Addresses Within a Short Walk

The A&G is not the only prominent building in Old Town sitting idle this fall. In the same September report, the Sun Herald described a mixed commercial market in a city with fast residential growth, and said rising construction costs were challenging developers.

The former Tripletails building, 113 South Beach Boulevard. This is the three-story, neon-green building down the street from the A&G. Tripletails served seafood there for more than a decade. According to the Sun Herald, it closed in January 2026, and the owners cited rising insurance rates and higher food costs. The 4,400-square-foot building went on the market in February at $2.35 million. By mid-September 2026 the price was down to about $2 million, and the listing pitched it as a possible destination restaurant, upscale retail space or mixed-use hospitality venue. Unlike the A&G, it was a working restaurant less than a year ago, and its kitchen-ready layout is part of the pitch.

The Historic L&N Train Depot, 1928 Depot Way. The city owns the depot. For 17 years the Alice Moseley Folk Art Museum occupied its second floor, until the City Council voted to end the lease. In September, Mayor Mike Favre told the Sun Herald that city leaders were weighing whether a local branch of Mississippi Main Street could take over the first floor and greet Amtrak riders arriving a few steps away. A visitor-facing use in the building closest to the train platform would be a natural fit.

The museum has a new home. After a temporary stay at 105 South Toulme Street, reported by WLOX, it reopened inside Gallery 220 at 220 Main Street, in space that once held Clay Creations. The Sea Coast Echo credited Mamie Hillery, who bought the Gallery 220 property, with making the move possible. Museum hours are 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Saturday and noon to 4 p.m. on Sunday. In practice, a folk art collection that sat upstairs in a train station is now in a storefront on Main Street.

Where the A&G's Next Act Will Show Up First

Three places will likely show the next plan before anything changes on the facade.

  1. The Historic Preservation Commission agenda. The 2024 flea market plan reached the commission with drawings attached, and any new use that changes entries, windows or parking at 150 North Beach Boulevard will likely go the same way.
  2. A change in who owns the building. MacPhaille told the Sun Herald in 2025 that he wanted to find "the right developer" with the means "to do something nice," and that he did not want the theater to become "just another bar or restaurant." A sale or long-term lease to a venue operator would be the first concrete sign of which plan won out.
  3. Progress on the school. MacPhaille linked the blues club idea to finishing the Second Street School condos, so construction there is the clock the theater's fallback plan runs on.

In 2025, Haas told the Sun Herald that the theater was "an icon of the Bay" and that the hope was someone "brings it back to life." Whoever buys or leases it will be starting from the 1927 theater Nolan designed, sloping floor and all.

At 124 Court Development, we follow what happens to Old Town's historic buildings because they shape the streets our residents walk every day. If you would like to talk about life a short walk from Beach Boulevard in a newly built home on Court Street, schedule a consultation with our team.

Let’s Get Started

Residential and commercial units available for consideration. For more information or to arrange a site visit, please call developer, Steve Drown, 228-313-1063 or email [email protected]